Use of geotechnologies in the reproduction and recovery of heritage, ethical reflection and case study

Authors

Keywords:

Conservation, Restoration, Ethics, Stone, Sculpture, CNC Reproduction

Abstract

All of us, as well as the objects that surrounds us, are in a permanent process of degradation for the simple reason that we are positioned on the surface of the Earth and interact with the atmosphere that surrounds us. The degradation of all things is an evolutionary process and inevitably leads to non-existence, within a more or less short time limit - at some point in the future, there will in fact be no pyramids in Egypt, no Mona Lisa in the Louvre, no Big Ben in London, at that point, it might consider prudent to have made at least a few copies; or not. We can also consider the hypothesis that, at that point, we have stopped giving importance to the past, only thinking about the immediate future. In this article we intend to present an ethical reflection on the crossroads at which we find ourselves and an example of a restoration that uses technology to “create new ancient art today”, but which maintains it our current reality, heritage that had already been lost (in terms of its physical integrity) to the restoration through traditional methods. As a final result of the work of all the experts involved, a CNC-machined stone reproduction was reinstalled in situ to replace the unrecoverable one that was originally situated within a symmetrical sculptural setting. The particularities of the equipment used that allowed this restoration challenge to be resolved are mentioned, as well as the ethical concerns that arose throughout the entire process.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biographies

Fernando Manuel da Conceição Costa, Techn&Art - Technology, Restoration and Arts Enhancement Center, Instituto Politécnico de Tomar, Portugal

Professor Adjunto do Instituto Politécnico de Tomar onde exerce funções docentes na Licenciatura em Conservação e Restauro desde 1994 e no Mestrado desde 2008. É Mestre em Recuperação do Património Arquitetónico e Paisagístico pela Universidade de Évora e possui título de Especialista na área de Materiais Pétreos. É membro do Centro de Investigação TECHN&ART e Coordenador do Curso Técnico Superior Profissional de Conservação e Talhe de Pedra. Tem desenvolvido diversos trabalhos na área de conservação e restauro de pedra em património classificado.

Maria Julia Sobral da Fonseca, Freelancer Conservation and Restoration designer for Classified Property Heritage

Has a degree in Stone Conservation and Restoration and a Master's Degree in Chemistry Applied to Cultural Heritage. She began his professional career as conservator-restorer in June 1997, quickly directing her professional activity towards archaeological sites as the Monastery of Santa Clara-a-Velha (Coimbra - 1997-1998, 2006-2008, 200-2014), the archaeological site of Idanha-a-Velha, Castelo Branco (1998-2000) and Monastery of S. João Tarouca (Lamego- 2000-2006). She also has experience as a trainer at the Professional School of Archaeology, Freixo, Marco de Canaveses (2001-2007), at the Italian Chamber of Commerce, in Porto (2002-2003) and in CEARTE, Coimbra (2014-2017), but also in supervision (Conservation and Restoration) of heritage enhancement projects in Monastery of Sta. Clara-a-Velha, Coimbra (2006-2008) and in the Cathedral of Viseu (2022-2023), and had a scholarship from the Foundation for Science and Technology (2006-2008). She is currently a freelancer Conservation and Restoration designer for Classified Property Heritage (Portugal – Lisbon’s Cathedral, Church of St. John the Baptist in Tomar, Church of St. Dominic in Viana do Castelo, Major Seminary in Coimbra and, Wall and Tower of the Blacksmiths in Guarda).

João Duarte, University of Coimbra

João Duarte, completed his PhD in Geological and Mining Engineering (Geotechnologies) in 2018/10/26 from the University of Coimbra, his MSc in Geological and Mining Engineering in 2010 from the University of Coimbra and his BSc in Geology in 1993 from the University of Coimbra. He is a Researcher at the Geosciences Center of the University of Coimbra and a Senior Technician at IQGeo - Serviços, Lda. He has published 10 articles in specialized journals. He has written 1 book chapter. He has supervised 2 master's dissertations and co-supervised 4. He participates and/or has participated in 3 projects. He has been a researcher in the field of Earth and Environmental Sciences - Geology, linked to the industry since 1993. He has worked in the exploration, exploitation and transformation of geological resources, in the fields of Geology and Geotechnics, Geological and Geotechnical Prospecting, Quarrying, Industry and Environment and Aerial (UAV) and Terrestrial Surveys. At the same time, he has carried out research in the areas of hydrogeological prospecting in Cape Verde and Portugal, planning of ornamental and industrial rock exploitation, monitoring of coastal erosion and recognition of archaeological structures, conservation and restoration of heritage using geotechnologies. He has also taken part in projects in the areas of tourism, the enhancement of geological, environmental and social heritage in Cape Verde, as well as geotechnological projects involving drones (UAVs). 1. Drones4Litter - Detection of Marine Litter in coastal areas using unmanned aerial systems (drones); 2. Georeferenced Information and Mapping Cabo Verde Tourism Resources; 3. Geoheritage of São Nicolau Island: Geotourist valorization (DRACAENA GEOPARK). He has been registered with the DGEG as the technical manager of quarries since 2004 and with the Order of Engineers in the specialty of Geological and Mining Engineering since 2022. He was designated Coordinator of IPN LABGEO in February 2024.

References

3D-ICONS - 3D Digitization of Icons of European Architectural and Archaeological Heritage. http://3dicons-project.eu/. [consulted: 03/04/2025].

APPELBAUM, B. (2010). ”Methodology Conservation Treatment”. Journal of the American Institute for Conservation. 49: 53-55. https://doi.org/10.2307/41320433

ARTEC 3D. “Scanner Artec Eva | Best Structured-light 3D Scanning Device”. https://www.artec3d.com/es/portable-3d-scanners/artec-eva?keyword=artec%20eva&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=12711727109&gbraid=0AAAAAD76GcMpmBOt1cxmF3Fdla1767R--&gclid=Cj0KCQiAyP3KBhD9ARIsAAJLnnamqGXIKw0-PO8zm8XQqZA5E2ZVZT4bod6hGtTEjlzUeyrp_jHyszUaAm-9EALw_wcB

BALBINO, F. (2021). “Caracterização Metrológica de Scanners Ópticos Tridimensionais por Projeção de Luz Estruturada Aplicados a Ensaios de Coletes Balísticos”, Pontifícia Universidade Católica, Rio de Janeiro.

BRANDI, C. (1977). Teoria del Restauro. Torino: Giulio Einaudi Editore.

BATLLE, J., MOUADDIB E., SALVI J. (1998). “Recent progress in coded structured light as a technique to solve the correspondence problem: a survey”. In Pattern Recognition, 31 (7): 963-982. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0031-3203(97)00074-5

BENJAMIN, W. (2017). “The work of art in the age of mechanical reproduction”. In: A Museum studies approach to heritage. Routledge, 226-243.

BRITISH MUSEUM, UK: “Jadeite Cabbage, Unknown, Qing dynasty (1644-1911), National Palace Museum, Taiwan”. https://artsandculture.google.com/story/hAXhy-4s3wl8KA?hl=en. [consulted: 03/04/2025].

CALVI, L., HOVER, M., de BRITO, M. (2024). “Preservation and memory in the age of new media”. In HeriCC 1ST International Conference Heritage, Conservation and Creativity - Cultural Heritage in transformation, TECHN&ART, Polytechnic University of Tomar, 9 October 2024

CARAVELLO, E. (2024). “Geotecnologie per i siti UNESCO del Mediterraneo. Il progetto iHeritage: ICT Mediterranean platform for UNESCO cultural heritage”. Bollettino della Società Geografica Italiana serie 14, 7(2): 169-179. https://doi.org/10.36253/bsgi-7450

EURONEWS. (2021). “O David, de Miguel Ângelo, está a ser reproduzido em 3D”. https://pt.euronews.com/cultura/2021/04/14/o-david-de-miguel-angelo-esta-a-ser-reproduzido-em-3d. [consulted: 3/4/2025].

FRESATOR. “Soluções para a indústria dos mármores, granitos e aglomerados”. https://www.fresator.pt/. [consulted: 03/04/2025].

KEMP, J. (2023). “Conservators, creativity, and control”. In Studies in Conservation. https://doi.org/10.1080/00393630.2025.2484910

LIBRARY OF CONGRESS, Sustainability of Digital Formats: Planning for Library of Congress Collections. “Polygon File Format (PLY) Family”. https://www.loc.gov/preservation/digital/formats/fdd/fdd000501.shtml. https://docs.fileformat.com/3d/ply/. [consulted: 03/04/2025].

LIU, J.; WILLKENS, D.;GENTRY, R. (2025). “Developing a Practice Based Guide to Terrestrial Laser Scanning (TLS) for Heritage Documentation”. Heritage, 8 (8), 313. https://doi.org/10.3390/heritage8080313

LOUVRE, Paris. https://www.louvre.fr/en/exhibitions-and-events/exhibitions/masterpieces-from-the-torlonia-collection. [consulted: 03/04/2025].

MORRIS, W. (1996). “Reading 31: Manifesto of the Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings”. In Historical and Philosophical Issues in the Conservation of Cultural Heritage, Berland, D. (coord). Los Angeles: The Getty Conservation Institute, 319 - 321.

NOGUEIRA, A., CHASQUEIRA, Â., TRIÃES, R. (2024) “Walking tour around the Creative Conservation interventions on Display”, TECHN&ART, Polytechnic University of Tomar, 9 October 2024.

PHILIPPOT, P. (1996). “Reading 38: Historic preservation: philosophy, criteria, guidelines, II”. In Historical and Philosophical Issues in the Conservation of Cultural Heritage, Berland, D. (coord). Los Angeles: The Getty Conservation Institute, 358 - 363.

PINELLI, O. R. (1996). “Reading 29: The surgery of memory: ancient sculptures and historical restorations”. In Historical and Philosophical Issues in the Conservation of Cultural Heritage, Berland, D. (coord). Los Angeles: The Getty Conservation Institute, 288 - 305.

SUCHOCKI, C., OKRÓJ S., BŁASZCZAK-BĄK, W. (2023). “ Methodology for the measurement and 3D modelling of cultural heritage: a case study of the Monument to the Polish Diaspora Bond with the Homeland”. Reports on Geodesy and Geoinformatics, 116: 1–8. https://doi.org/10.2478/rgg-2023-0005

TRUE, M (2003). “Changings approaches to conservation”. In History of Restoration of Ancient Stone Sculptures, Gilman B. (coord). Los Angeles: The Getty Conservation Institute, 1 - 11.

VIÑAS, S. M. (2003). Teoria contemporânea de la Restauración. Madrid: Editorial Síntesis, S. A.

A. M. V. (1996). “Restoration and Anti-Restoration - Introdution to part V”. In Historical and Philosophical Issues in the Conservation of Cultural Heritage, Berland, D. (coord). Los Angeles: The Getty Conservation Institute, 308 - 313.

Published

2026-01-20

How to Cite

Costa, F. M. da C., Sobral da Fonseca, M. J., & Duarte, J. (2026). Use of geotechnologies in the reproduction and recovery of heritage, ethical reflection and case study. Ge-conservacion, 29(1), 06–17. Retrieved from https://revista.ge-iic.com/index.php/revista/article/view/1398